By August that farm clay dries into something you can barely get a screwdriver into, and almost everybody who calls me about it uses the word compacted. Sometimes that is exactly right, and when it is, core aeration is the only tool that relieves it without killing the lawn to get there. Everything else that truly loosens soil, tillage or a full renovation, takes the existing turf out with it. So I will never tell you cores do nothing for compaction. That is just as wrong as the advertising going the other direction.
The two honest qualifiers are density and duration. Research counts cultivation in cores per square foot, not in passes, and Kansas State puts effective cultivation at 15 to 30 cores per square foot. A single pass with a commercial spoon aerator delivers roughly half of that or less, which is why one lap around the yard produces no measurable change in bulk density. It takes two or three passes over the same ground. The frequency work agrees: moving from one aeration event a year to three cut bulk density by 5 to 9 percent and surface hardness by 5 to 19 percent. Real, modest, and it takes repetition. I put the core density numbers and the studies here.
Duration is where our clay gets a vote. Holes close in weeks, not seasons. The clay swells with the next rain, settles, and takes its shape back.
Then there is the part nobody selling aeration says out loud: destructive compaction is uncommon in a lawn. Nature undoes it constantly through root channels, soil biology, and the freeze and thaw cycling a Zone 6b to 7a winter delivers. Real compaction is nearly always something people did in the same footprint over and over. On a farm-country property that usually means a truck or a trailer parked on the same patch of grass, a mower run on the identical track every week, or the worn path everybody takes to the shop. Move the traffic and you fix more than the aerator will.